Updated: 04/24/2017 04:15 PM | First Published: 08/21/2016 02:54 PM

James Lafferty dated two of his One Tree Hill co-stars

James Lafferty with jet black hair, he's wearing a button down shirt with the top button opened
Lafferty and Sophia Bush dated for a few months and ended their relationship in 2009. He also dated actress Shantel VanSanten.

Prev 1 of 5 James Lafferty with Bethany Joy Lenz (L) and Jackson Brundage (R) Next